{ "schemaVersion": 1, "snapshot_date": "2026-10-11", "snapshotStage": "post-locator-normalization", "verifyScope": { "sourceCommit": "5996577cd2da067e72b700239bd621d9cd7afa90", "sourceRootAlias": "guide-worktree-dist", "publishedRootAlias": "publication-worktree/docs/research/matrixspec-rsi", "scope": "26 evidence files directly linked by the current index, generation-history page, or evolution-entries page: aggregate result JSON, cross-generation summary, ledger, history, anonymous RCA, and H0601 effective-result records.", "sourceFileCount": 26, "directlyLinkedPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html", "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html" ], "excluded": [ "previous/ subtree", "unlinked archive material", "raw-session files and contents", "secret or credential files", "page HTML/CSS/JavaScript assets" ], "comparisonMethod": "SHA-256, byte size, and bytewise comparison against explicit original authority paths; source and published locators are recorded separately." }, "sourceFileCount": 26, "sourceFiles": [ { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h0-luna/generation-result.json", "sourceSHA256": "200182ea5b49517e1e5341355a879bb36e5bf9d1d65c07070b0d578d31be1df6", "sourceBytes": 12216, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h0-luna/generation-result.json", "publishedSHA256": "200182ea5b49517e1e5341355a879bb36e5bf9d1d65c07070b0d578d31be1df6", "publishedBytes": 12216, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "generation-result", "generationId": "H0", "declaredFields": [ "generationId", "status", "expectedValidCells", "validCells" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/generation-result.json", "originalSHA256": "200182ea5b49517e1e5341355a879bb36e5bf9d1d65c07070b0d578d31be1df6", "originalBytes": 12216, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h03/generation-result.json", "sourceSHA256": "48011a5364a7da42d8b6426e39864aee5cfa3f0f2fcc3e1c2e308ebeceeca6bf", "sourceBytes": 13216, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h03/generation-result.json", "publishedSHA256": "48011a5364a7da42d8b6426e39864aee5cfa3f0f2fcc3e1c2e308ebeceeca6bf", "publishedBytes": 13216, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "generation-result", "generationId": "H03", "generationBundleId": "H03-FORMAL-20260811-R1", "status": "complete" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:h02-p01.hYpvVN", "relativePath": "workarean/experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h03-formal/reports/generation-result.json", "originalSHA256": "48011a5364a7da42d8b6426e39864aee5cfa3f0f2fcc3e1c2e308ebeceeca6bf", "originalBytes": 13216, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h04/generation-result.json", "sourceSHA256": "3ccddb992ef2cbc7691a81440c7024aba42c15fdbdce2f1840bcf8ae6ab8c76c", "sourceBytes": 13244, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h04/generation-result.json", "publishedSHA256": "3ccddb992ef2cbc7691a81440c7024aba42c15fdbdce2f1840bcf8ae6ab8c76c", "publishedBytes": 13244, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "generation-result", "generationId": "H04", "generationBundleId": "H04-FORMAL-20260812-R1", "status": "complete" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:h04-controller-evidence-bound-review", "relativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h04-formal/reports/generation-result.json", "originalSHA256": "3ccddb992ef2cbc7691a81440c7024aba42c15fdbdce2f1840bcf8ae6ab8c76c", "originalBytes": 13244, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h05/generation-result.json", "sourceSHA256": "bcb01e497e787d6bd24f19ad8f1b80c97f19fbaa360d4543a55c45d20c7e7f09", "sourceBytes": 13673, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h05/generation-result.json", "publishedSHA256": "bcb01e497e787d6bd24f19ad8f1b80c97f19fbaa360d4543a55c45d20c7e7f09", "publishedBytes": 13673, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "generation-result", "generationId": "H05", "generationBundleId": "H05-P04-FAST-FORMAL-20260812-R1", "status": "complete" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:h05-p04-authority-conflict", "relativePath": "workarean/experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h05-formal/reports/generation-result.json", "originalSHA256": "bcb01e497e787d6bd24f19ad8f1b80c97f19fbaa360d4543a55c45d20c7e7f09", "originalBytes": 13673, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h052/verified-results.json", "sourceSHA256": "22d6f1d994df6ec5f57d7526eb3401bb97787e576b7fe2cfdfd09e56eb836312", "sourceBytes": 7411, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h052/verified-results.json", "publishedSHA256": "22d6f1d994df6ec5f57d7526eb3401bb97787e576b7fe2cfdfd09e56eb836312", "publishedBytes": 7411, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "selected-results-snapshot", "identityDeclaredInPayload": false, "recordShape": "runs[] with per-run scores" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:88bc", "relativePath": "workarean/.scratch/h052-judge/verified-results.json", "originalSHA256": "22d6f1d994df6ec5f57d7526eb3401bb97787e576b7fe2cfdfd09e56eb836312", "originalBytes": 7411, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/bare/generation-result.json", "sourceSHA256": "1e92fc11fc710e1ac2f91d187691374f27cc19a80687b74663d170cd855a5e36", "sourceBytes": 16161, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/bare/generation-result.json", "publishedSHA256": "9dc09bd6e45ab7ed36ff8b3ebf8d37d4d342a25182f39e3fa7671e50dc58f5a4", "publishedBytes": 16049, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "comparator-generation-result", "conditionId": "bare", "generationBundleId": "BARE-BASELINE-20260813-R1", "status": "complete" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:no-sdd-bare-baseline", "relativePath": "workarean/experiments/bare-baseline-20260813-r1/reports/generation-result.json", "originalSHA256": "1e92fc11fc710e1ac2f91d187691374f27cc19a80687b74663d170cd855a5e36", "originalBytes": 16161, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "tasks[0].resultPath", "tasks[1].resultPath", "tasks[2].resultPath", "tasks[3].resultPath", "tasks[4].resultPath", "tasks[5].resultPath", "tasks[6].resultPath", "tasks[7].resultPath" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "sourceSHA256": "1cba09a3c007c33a703870a4caddca37805ea6329b250a166097f808077831f0", "sourceBytes": 10592, "publishedRelativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "publishedSHA256": "f8fc48a76911425ba17cc77d8ed68e9598d59024a8f16490a1768b02f6598d71", "publishedBytes": 10466, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "complete-derived-summary", "status": "complete-derived-summary", "denominator": { "tasks": 8, "selectedCells": 24, "judgeOutputs": 48, "d8Included": true, "d1ThroughD7OnlyViewPublished": false } }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "originalSHA256": "2c80131a4cf516305a7eb3cef87dca1e6d95e6edba755d090edc227ac7d83ca9", "originalBytes": 9146, "status": "byte_mismatch" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "comparatorBaselines[0].judgeRecovery.invalidAttemptArchive", "comparatorBaselines[0].judgeRecovery.receipt", "comparatorBaselines[0].result", "d8Governance.h052CorrectedD8.audit", "d8Governance.h052CorrectedD8.campaign", "d8Governance.h052CorrectedD8.result", "views[7].selectionAuthority", "views[8].effectiveSummary", "views[8].judgeReplacementAuthority" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/model-evaluation-ledger.md", "sourceSHA256": "d3e1573ff5439f75ae300778e3a31d3d642c1585cccb91c06c0dbb1d69690b0d", "sourceBytes": 150246, "publishedRelativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/model-evaluation-ledger.md", "publishedSHA256": "6f02d12dc1528fbd83b59e082bc836e9b4aa42027ec22ea32410552d337e29df", "publishedBytes": 151731, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "reconciliation-index", "declaredTitle": "MatrixSpec 模型运行与评测对账表" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/model-evaluation-ledger.md", "originalSHA256": "f7739f26924f44642d3878cb7a51cc461b4da01c1e02d4d1ce0c1c00b18ae5fd", "originalBytes": 147472, "status": "byte_mismatch" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "contentLine[1018]", "contentLine[1078]", "contentLine[1094]", "contentLine[1161]", "contentLine[1197]", "contentLine[853]", "contentLine[854]", "contentLine[941]", "contentLine[966]" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.md", "sourceSHA256": "10935975e70d1ce14014a62f3fcd43266881d7e7fc783f30d48704920671af77", "sourceBytes": 31685, "publishedRelativePath": "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.md", "publishedSHA256": "e601fb0682968ed04636eb9fd8ce5d224f0c0d90813386fe5cb66c1731c13f0b", "publishedBytes": 31942, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "decision-and-results-index", "declaredTitle": "MatrixSpec 代际演进简史" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.md", "originalSHA256": "0ebf06077895eb41154f978e4ac530039dba88dc55bf12a5756cb9fe4124c491", "originalBytes": 30005, "status": "byte_mismatch" }, "normalization": "link_or_locator_rewrite", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/h0601-effective-summary.md", "sourceSHA256": "99d916039fb74f38726f9e59723b9b1c1f1b07a3f3ff4d972fa0f018ac74d696", "sourceBytes": 5251, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/h0601-effective-summary.md", "publishedSHA256": "f417fbcbe56fe8bf63a0ebf438192c9e6d001fc199465090649337660f56d38b", "publishedBytes": 5755, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "effective-judge-result-summary", "conditionId": "H0601-da2b42b", "judgeScoreSum": 4528, "effectiveJudgeOutputs": 48 }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:3678", "relativePath": "workarean/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/h0601-effective-summary.md", "originalSHA256": "99d916039fb74f38726f9e59723b9b1c1f1b07a3f3ff4d972fa0f018ac74d696", "originalBytes": 5251, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "link_or_locator_rewrite", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/promotion.json", "sourceSHA256": "7e1885d0eb79f375947f80aaefa4544863c377f465e4785387a2c24f6387b060", "sourceBytes": 1386, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/promotion.json", "publishedSHA256": "7e1885d0eb79f375947f80aaefa4544863c377f465e4785387a2c24f6387b060", "publishedBytes": 1386, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "judge-source-slot-promotion", "declaredFields": [ "packageHash", "invalidResult", "replacementResult", "promotedAtUtc" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:3678", "relativePath": "workarean/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/promotion.json", "originalSHA256": "7e1885d0eb79f375947f80aaefa4544863c377f465e4785387a2c24f6387b060", "originalBytes": 1386, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/bundle-manifest.json", "sourceSHA256": "977ab4e3f5bbcabd6c5d872503f8b9f5d69e11f6868af4d03338685e803391ec", "sourceBytes": 42789, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/bundle-manifest.json", "publishedSHA256": "977ab4e3f5bbcabd6c5d872503f8b9f5d69e11f6868af4d03338685e803391ec", "publishedBytes": 42789, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-bundle-manifest", "generation": "H0", "analysisRunId": "h0-root-cause-20260809-a" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H0/generation-H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/bundle-manifest.json", "originalSHA256": "977ab4e3f5bbcabd6c5d872503f8b9f5d69e11f6868af4d03338685e803391ec", "originalBytes": 42789, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/coverage.json", "sourceSHA256": "d41e7f080f47f331ea06b9ba09a662c372f5d64d24f3a3311a96590fe18e7942", "sourceBytes": 19266, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/coverage.json", "publishedSHA256": "0c3a3498beaa1c07feaea3aaa319552ab81136e99c3a3ab62dc8728991523a4d", "publishedBytes": 18906, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-coverage", "generation": "H0", "analysisRunId": "h0-root-cause-20260809-a" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H0/generation-H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/coverage.json", "originalSHA256": "d41e7f080f47f331ea06b9ba09a662c372f5d64d24f3a3311a96590fe18e7942", "originalBytes": 19266, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "cells[0].taskSummaryPath", "cells[10].taskSummaryPath", "cells[11].taskSummaryPath", "cells[12].taskSummaryPath", "cells[13].taskSummaryPath", "cells[14].taskSummaryPath", "cells[15].taskSummaryPath", "cells[16].taskSummaryPath", "cells[17].taskSummaryPath", "cells[18].taskSummaryPath", "cells[19].taskSummaryPath", "cells[1].taskSummaryPath", "cells[20].taskSummaryPath", "cells[21].taskSummaryPath", "cells[22].taskSummaryPath", "cells[23].taskSummaryPath", "cells[2].taskSummaryPath", "cells[3].taskSummaryPath", "cells[4].taskSummaryPath", "cells[5].taskSummaryPath", "cells[6].taskSummaryPath", "cells[7].taskSummaryPath", "cells[8].taskSummaryPath", "cells[9].taskSummaryPath" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/handoff.json", "sourceSHA256": "c1c2bf173601c32025731b137c38dc4c3423872f22b48b1852674d96d92d31fd", "sourceBytes": 1001, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/handoff.json", "publishedSHA256": "c1c2bf173601c32025731b137c38dc4c3423872f22b48b1852674d96d92d31fd", "publishedBytes": 1001, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-handoff", "generation": "H0", "analysisRunId": "h0-root-cause-20260809-a" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H0/generation-H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/handoff.json", "originalSHA256": "c1c2bf173601c32025731b137c38dc4c3423872f22b48b1852674d96d92d31fd", "originalBytes": 1001, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/pattern-evidence/all-cells.json", "sourceSHA256": "c3793871a0569fb545adeea627de18e02953514ffcf4bbcda10972e2f7fc6dcc", "sourceBytes": 646165, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/pattern-evidence/all-cells.json", "publishedSHA256": "c3793871a0569fb545adeea627de18e02953514ffcf4bbcda10972e2f7fc6dcc", "publishedBytes": 646165, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-pattern-evidence", "generation": "H0", "analysisRunId": "h0-root-cause-20260809-a", "rawSessionContentsIncluded": false }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H0/generation-H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/pattern-evidence/all-cells.json", "originalSHA256": "c3793871a0569fb545adeea627de18e02953514ffcf4bbcda10972e2f7fc6dcc", "originalBytes": 646165, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/weakness-shortlist.json", "sourceSHA256": "d0ef0131d744bb02a4921843b909481628d56096cd040b23284a236c815615b4", "sourceBytes": 38966, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/weakness-shortlist.json", "publishedSHA256": "d0ef0131d744bb02a4921843b909481628d56096cd040b23284a236c815615b4", "publishedBytes": 38966, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-weakness-shortlist", "generation": "H0", "analysisRunId": "h0-root-cause-20260809-a" }, "referencedByPages": [ "index.html", "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H0/generation-H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/weakness-shortlist.json", "originalSHA256": "d0ef0131d744bb02a4921843b909481628d56096cd040b23284a236c815615b4", "originalBytes": 38966, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "899b4cf1c9889a554b91d1eeb0f6a4a79f05fa689a098dedcf418f280f3de2e0", "sourceBytes": 10512, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "3689604c37d636ec81e8da329a5ecd45aa058fdc2a4e4c021f910fe7951443e8", "publishedBytes": 10530, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-proposals", "generation": "H1", "analysisRunId": "h1-root-cause-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "generationProvenance", "analysis", "cards" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H1/generation-H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "originalSHA256": "899b4cf1c9889a554b91d1eeb0f6a4a79f05fa689a098dedcf418f280f3de2e0", "originalBytes": 10512, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "generationProvenance.temporaryAnalysisRoot" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "e3443e5f19085bf71cd8f0f675ce291c65b4dd2b5a2441fcf655b2b896c52409", "sourceBytes": 8834, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "30318248514c0c68137c5c60b07015717e4812bd456966616a696b09e6edad5e", "publishedBytes": 8891, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-weakness-shortlist", "generation": "H1", "analysisRunId": "h1-root-cause-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "analysis", "processProvenance", "primaryView" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H1/generation-H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "originalSHA256": "e3443e5f19085bf71cd8f0f675ce291c65b4dd2b5a2441fcf655b2b896c52409", "originalBytes": 8834, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "path_or_locator_sanitization", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [ { "category": "absolute_local_path", "fieldPaths": [ "processProvenance.temporaryArtifacts.root", "processProvenance.temporaryArtifacts.solRootCause" ] } ], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "87f037d38b29677034ebf000d42ba45ceae0fffc0dde0650e06f5b9a7f01b96f", "sourceBytes": 11617, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "87f037d38b29677034ebf000d42ba45ceae0fffc0dde0650e06f5b9a7f01b96f", "publishedBytes": 11617, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-proposals", "generation": "H02", "analysisRunId": "h02-root-cause-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "parent_harness", "analysis_run_id", "confirmed_weaknesses", "proposals" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H02/generation-H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "originalSHA256": "87f037d38b29677034ebf000d42ba45ceae0fffc0dde0650e06f5b9a7f01b96f", "originalBytes": 11617, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "909e8b04bd8a459628818f61d3e4549c8fb76b24c21ec3a0917439318628fd25", "sourceBytes": 17206, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "909e8b04bd8a459628818f61d3e4549c8fb76b24c21ec3a0917439318628fd25", "publishedBytes": 17206, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-weakness-shortlist", "generation": "H02", "analysisRunId": "h02-root-cause-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "miner", "coverage", "batch_assessment", "weaknesses" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H02/generation-H02/h02-root-cause-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "originalSHA256": "909e8b04bd8a459628818f61d3e4549c8fb76b24c21ec3a0917439318628fd25", "originalBytes": 17206, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "e11ad441c965dc7ce5f5f67494c3267d39bef723b3d22b0fe6d5781b7c4bd707", "sourceBytes": 4900, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "e11ad441c965dc7ce5f5f67494c3267d39bef723b3d22b0fe6d5781b7c4bd707", "publishedBytes": 4900, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-agent-derived-RCA-proposals", "generation": "H02", "analysisRunId": "h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "analysis", "status", "cards" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H02/generation-H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/proposals.yaml", "originalSHA256": "e11ad441c965dc7ce5f5f67494c3267d39bef723b3d22b0fe6d5781b7c4bd707", "originalBytes": 4900, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "c17d79511548f7796e37a2b54d393c8225d92254174c1624155dd9ad0b47e596", "sourceBytes": 8039, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "c17d79511548f7796e37a2b54d393c8225d92254174c1624155dd9ad0b47e596", "publishedBytes": 8039, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-agent-derived-RCA-weaknesses", "generation": "H02", "analysisRunId": "h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "analysis", "primaryView", "weaknesses" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "workarena-source", "relativePath": ".scratch/matrixspec-root-cause-analysis/harness-H02/generation-H02/h02-agent-analysis-20260811-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "originalSHA256": "c17d79511548f7796e37a2b54d393c8225d92254174c1624155dd9ad0b47e596", "originalBytes": 8039, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/proposals.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "76f2ab6cba426ff1c992d1175371d3ad9a8356406f2de814e1b78a0509e716c3", "sourceBytes": 13366, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/proposals.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "76f2ab6cba426ff1c992d1175371d3ad9a8356406f2de814e1b78a0509e716c3", "publishedBytes": 13366, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-proposals", "generation": "H04", "analysisRunId": "h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "parentHarness", "analysisRunId", "userConfirmation", "proposals" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:1389", "relativePath": "workarean/.scratch/matrixspec-root-cause/harness-H04/generation-H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/proposals.yaml", "originalSHA256": null, "originalBytes": null, "status": "archived_copy_only" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "36a258203b131bd571dd74ce90609f853dc70a4798f6109fef9f5b89c432fc77", "sourceBytes": 17524, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "36a258203b131bd571dd74ce90609f853dc70a4798f6109fef9f5b89c432fc77", "publishedBytes": 17524, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-weakness-shortlist", "generation": "H04", "analysisRunId": "h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "parentHarness", "generation", "generationBundleId", "analysisRunId", "weaknesses" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:1389", "relativePath": "workarean/.scratch/matrixspec-root-cause/harness-H04/generation-H04/h04-postformal-20260812-019ff55f-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "originalSHA256": null, "originalBytes": null, "status": "archived_copy_only" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/proposals.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "a864620f181ad77e2b5e8740cd2055743aebbb5bc0c4ff035321dfcda81405e7", "sourceBytes": 14693, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/proposals.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "a864620f181ad77e2b5e8740cd2055743aebbb5bc0c4ff035321dfcda81405e7", "publishedBytes": 14693, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-proposals", "generation": "H052", "analysisRunId": "h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "analysis", "status", "cards" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:88bc", "relativePath": "workarean/.scratch/matrixspec-root-cause/harness-H052/generation-H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/proposals.yaml", "originalSHA256": "a864620f181ad77e2b5e8740cd2055743aebbb5bc0c4ff035321dfcda81405e7", "originalBytes": 14693, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] }, { "sourceRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "sourceSHA256": "3de42f821d1c7f3b014c2a127aafb976c492bb290744a1b90c1227cfb5229b09", "sourceBytes": 15878, "publishedRelativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "publishedSHA256": "3de42f821d1c7f3b014c2a127aafb976c492bb290744a1b90c1227cfb5229b09", "publishedBytes": 15878, "declaredAuthority": { "type": "anonymous-RCA-weakness-shortlist", "generation": "H052", "analysisRunId": "h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a", "authorityFieldNames": [ "analysis", "primaryView", "weaknesses" ] }, "referencedByPages": [ "docs/matrixspec-evolution-entries.html", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.html" ], "originalVerification": { "rootAlias": "historical-worktree:88bc", "relativePath": "workarean/.scratch/matrixspec-root-cause/harness-H052/generation-H052/h052-postformal-20260814-019ff5c4-a/weakness-shortlist.yaml", "originalSHA256": "3de42f821d1c7f3b014c2a127aafb976c492bb290744a1b90c1227cfb5229b09", "originalBytes": 15878, "status": "byte_equal" }, "normalization": "unchanged", "sourcePrivacyFindings": [], "publishedResidualFindings": [] } ], "privacyReview": { "screenedCategories": [ "absolute local paths", "email addresses", "account/user identifiers", "API/token-key/credential fields", "secret-like token values" ], "sourceAbsolutePathFindingCount": 6, "sourceSensitiveValuesFound": { "email": false, "accountOrUserId": false, "tokenOrCredentialKey": false, "secretLikeValue": false }, "publishedResidualFindingCount": 0, "publishedStatus": "clear", "rawSessionContentsRead": false, "rawSessionFilesPackaged": false, "secretOrCredentialFilesRead": false, "findingPolicy": "Only field paths/document line positions and categories are recorded; matched values are omitted." }, "originalComparisonSummary": { "byteEqual": 21, "byteMismatch": 3, "archivedCopyOnly": 2 }, "publishedComparisonSummary": { "byteEqualToSourceSnapshot": 18, "transformedForPublication": 8, "residualSensitiveFindings": 0 }, "resultsSummary": { "measurementUnit": "24 selected cells and 48 Judge outputs where the condition uses the full Judge bundle.", "records": [ { "conditionId": "H0-LUNA-XHIGH-20260809", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 18, "productVerificationPassed": 19, "auditFindingRuns": 0, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": null, "mean": 90.125 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 597146805, "toolCalls": 6592, "credits": 6903.95, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h0-luna/generation-result.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[0].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[0].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[0].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[0].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[0].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[0].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[0].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[0].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[0].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[0].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[0].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[0].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[0].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "directGenerationResult": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h0-luna/generation-result.json", "directComparison": { "status": "selected_count_workflow_verification_and_cost_match_cross_summary", "directValidCells": 24, "directWorkflowCompleted": 18, "directVerificationPassed": 19, "directCandidateCost": { "tokens": 597146805, "toolCalls": 6592, "credits": 6903.95 } } }, { "conditionId": "H0-TERRA-HIGH-20260809", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 14, "productVerificationPassed": 15, "auditFindingRuns": 0, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": null, "mean": 88.0625 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 292164097, "toolCalls": 4386, "credits": 3776.08, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[1].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[1].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[1].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[1].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[1].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[1].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[1].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[1].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[1].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[1].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[1].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[1].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[1].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "authorityNote": "This is the H0 Terra/high model condition; the linked closure has no separate Terra/high generation-result JSON." }, { "conditionId": "H03-FORMAL-20260811-R1", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 18, "productVerificationPassed": 18, "auditFindingRuns": 0, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": null, "mean": 94.8958333333 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 276702480, "toolCalls": 4279, "credits": 3917.75, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h03/generation-result.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[4].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[4].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[4].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[4].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[4].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[4].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[4].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[4].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[4].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[4].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[4].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[4].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[4].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "directGenerationResult": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h03/generation-result.json", "directComparison": { "status": "selected_count_workflow_verification_and_cost_match_cross_summary", "directValidCells": 24, "directWorkflowCompleted": 18, "directVerificationPassed": 18, "directCandidateCost": { "tokens": 276702480, "toolCalls": 4279, "credits": 3917.75 } } }, { "conditionId": "H04-FORMAL-20260812-R1", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 12, "productVerificationPassed": 17, "auditFindingRuns": 0, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": null, "mean": 89.7916666667 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 219748287, "toolCalls": 3605, "credits": 3370.82, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h04/generation-result.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[5].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[5].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[5].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[5].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[5].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[5].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[5].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[5].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[5].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[5].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[5].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[5].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[5].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "directGenerationResult": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h04/generation-result.json", "directComparison": { "status": "selected_count_workflow_verification_and_cost_match_cross_summary", "directValidCells": 24, "directWorkflowCompleted": 12, "directVerificationPassed": 17, "directCandidateCost": { "tokens": 219748287, "toolCalls": 3605, "credits": 3370.82 } } }, { "conditionId": "H05-P04-FAST-FORMAL-20260812-R1", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 15, "productVerificationPassed": 20, "auditFindingRuns": 0, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": null, "mean": 95.0 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 259151137, "toolCalls": 4082, "credits": 3913.95, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h05/generation-result.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[6].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[6].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[6].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[6].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[6].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[6].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[6].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[6].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[6].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[6].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[6].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[6].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[6].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "directGenerationResult": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h05/generation-result.json", "directComparison": { "status": "selected_count_workflow_verification_and_cost_match_cross_summary", "directValidCells": 24, "directWorkflowCompleted": 15, "directVerificationPassed": 20, "directCandidateCost": { "tokens": 259151137, "toolCalls": 4082, "credits": 3913.95 } } }, { "conditionId": "H052-MATRIXSPEC-LEAN-V1-CORRECTED-D8", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 24, "productVerificationPassed": 19, "auditFindingRuns": 3, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": 4453, "mean": 92.7708333333 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 116857308, "toolCalls": 1258, "credits": 1891.35391, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h052/verified-results.json" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[7].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[7].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[7].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[7].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[7].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[7].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[7].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[7].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[7].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[7].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[7].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[7].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[7].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json" }, { "conditionId": "H0601-da2b42b", "selectedCells": 24, "validCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 24, "productVerificationPassed": null, "auditFindingRuns": null, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": 4528, "mean": 94.3333333333 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 84836263, "toolCalls": 1199, "credits": 1171.61, "scope": "Candidate/Harness-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/h0601-effective-summary.md" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "selectedCells": "views[8].selectedCells", "workflowCompleted": "views[8].workflowCompleted", "productVerificationPassed": "views[8].productVerificationPassed", "treatmentAuditPassed": "views[8].treatmentAuditPassed", "externalFocusedTestsPassed": "views[8].externalFocusedTestsPassed", "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": "views[8].preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed", "auditFindingRuns": "views[8].auditFindingRuns", "judgeOutputs": "views[8].judgeOutputs", "judgeScoreSum": "views[8].judgeScoreSum", "judgeMean": "views[8].judgeMean", "candidateCost.tokens": "views[8].candidateCost.tokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "views[8].candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "views[8].candidateCost.credits" }, "metricOrigin": "cross-generation-summary.json", "verificationMetrics": { "treatmentAuditPassed": 13, "externalFocusedTestsPassed": 18, "preHiddenVisibleVerificationPassed": 9, "doNotMergeIntoSingleQualityMetric": true } }, { "conditionId": "bare", "generationBundleId": "BARE-BASELINE-20260813-R1", "validCells": 24, "candidateTerminalCompleted": 24, "focusedAcceptancePassed": 17, "judge": { "outputs": 48, "scoreSum": 3477, "mean": 72.4375 }, "candidateCost": { "tokens": 42327170, "toolCalls": 721, "credits": 553.842237, "scope": "Candidate-only" }, "sourceFiles": [ "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/bare/generation-result.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/model-evaluation-ledger.md", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.md" ], "sourceFieldPaths": { "validCells": "generation-result.json.validCells", "candidateTerminalCompleted": "generation-result.json.candidateTerminalCompleted", "focusedAcceptancePassed": "generation-result.json.focusedAcceptancePassed", "judgeOutputs": "generation-result.json.judgeOutputs", "reportedMean": "generation-result.json.meanJudgeScore", "exactMean": "cross-generation-summary.json.comparatorBaselines[0].judgeMean", "judgeScoreSum": "cross-generation-summary.json.comparatorBaselines[0].judgeScoreSum", "candidateCost.tokens": "generation-result.json.candidateCost.totalTokens", "candidateCost.toolCalls": "generation-result.json.candidateCost.toolCalls", "candidateCost.credits": "generation-result.json.candidateCost.credits" }, "directReportedMean": 72.44, "exactMean": 72.4375, "meanNote": "The direct result rounds meanJudgeScore to 2 decimals; 3,477 / 48 is 72.4375." } ], "precisionNotes": [ { "conditionId": "bare", "exactMean": 72.4375, "directResultMean": 72.44, "note": "same 3,477/48 score basis; two-decimal result field vs four-decimal cross-summary/page presentation" }, { "conditionId": "H052-MATRIXSPEC-LEAN-V1-CORRECTED-D8", "exactMean": 92.7708333333, "displayedMean": "92.7708", "note": "display precision only for the corrected aggregate; linked verified-results selection has a separate scope mismatch recorded above" }, { "conditionId": "H0601-da2b42b", "exactMean": 94.3333333333, "displayedMean": "94.3333 / 94.33", "note": "same 4,528/48 score basis at shorter display precision" } ], "sourceVsPublishedJsonComparison": { "jsonFilesCompared": 13, "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true, "perFile": [ { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h0-luna/generation-result.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h03/generation-result.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h04/generation-result.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h05/generation-result.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h052/verified-results.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/bare/generation-result.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/results/H0601/campaigns/cli-item-list-fields-matrixspec-lean-h0601-eval-r1-judge-recovery-20260814-r1/promotion.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/bundle-manifest.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/coverage.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/handoff.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/pattern-evidence/all-cells.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true }, { "relativePath": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/analyses/H0/h0-root-cause-20260809-a/weakness-shortlist.json", "nonLocatorFieldsEqual": true } ] }, "crossGenerationSummaryVsOriginal": { "comparison": "selected_metric_fields_equal", "byteComparison": "byte_mismatch", "note": "The source snapshot differs bytewise from the original summary; selected condition metrics and costs match." }, "pageAndLedgerFigureCheck": { "status": "displayed figures agree at their printed precision except the H052 linked snapshot scope mismatch documented below.", "documents": [ "index.html", "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/model-evaluation-ledger.md", "docs/matrixspec-generation-evolution-history.md" ] } }, "discrepancies": [ { "conditionId": "H052-MATRIXSPEC-LEAN-V1-CORRECTED-D8", "status": "scope_mismatch", "linkedSelectionSnapshot": { "sourceFile": "archive/matrixspec-evolution/evaluations/h052/verified-results.json", "runs": 24, "judgeOutputs": 48, "judgeScoreSum": 4375, "judgeMean": 91.14583333333333, "D8JudgeOutputs": 6, "D8JudgeScoreSum": 384 }, "correctedComplete24CellSummary": { "sourceFile": "experiments/matrixspec-harness-evolution-h0/reports/cross-generation-summary.json", "selectedCells": 24, "workflowCompleted": 24, "productVerificationPassed": 19, "auditFindingRuns": 3, "judgeOutputs": 48, "judgeScoreSum": 4453, "judgeMean": 92.7708333333, "D8JudgeOutputs": 6, "D8JudgeScoreSum": 462 }, "delta": { "judgeScoreSum": 78, "D8JudgeScoreSum": 78 }, "interpretation": "The selected-results snapshot and corrected complete aggregate do not describe the same D8 selection. The ledger documents that corrected H052 uses a fresh D8 evaluation while retaining the older D8 evidence. Keep both records distinct; do not rewrite the measured scope." } ], "packagingDecision": { "publishableMaterial": "Directly linked aggregate results, ledger/history, anonymous RCA cards and H0601 effective-summary/promotion records after path/link locator normalization.", "requiresRedaction": "Source absolute-path locators are listed in sourcePrivacyFindings and have been normalized in the publication snapshot.", "mustNotPackage": [ "raw sessions", "secret/credential files", "unlinked previous snapshots" ], "measurementIntegrity": "Structured aggregate JSON non-locator fields compare equal between source and published copies; no numeric or hash fields changed in the checked JSON set." } }