schemaVersion: 1 analysis: parentHarness: H1 generation: H1 analysisRunId: h1-root-cause-20260811-a stableNamespace: H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a authorityClass: user-confirmed-derived-hypotheses processProvenance: bundleExport: complete lunaPatternExtraction: status: complete model: gpt-5.6-luna reasoningEffort: xhigh invocation: local-codex-exec-ephemeral-ignore-user-config-read-only batchShape: 3 batches x 8 cells acceptedOutputs: 24 solRootCauseMining: status: complete model: gpt-5.6-sol reasoningEffort: high invocation: one-single-full-batch-call input: all 24 accepted Pattern Evidence plus coverage, outcomes and counterexamples coordinator: model: gpt-5.6-sol reasoningEffort: xhigh action: audited the model outputs and submitted only the Weakness shortlist at the first user gate confirmationSource: fixed-model-analysis-then-user-confirmation note: >- The prescribed Luna then Sol analysis completed before the user confirmed W-01, W-03 and W-04. Accepted Pattern Evidence and the Sol aggregate remain in a temporary directory and were not copied into this analysis workspace; failed drafts and retry outputs were excluded from aggregation. temporaryArtifacts: root: historical-temporary://matrixspec-h1-luna.1kvhTP solRootCause: historical-temporary://matrixspec-h1-luna.1kvhTP/sol-root-cause.json persistence: temporary-not-copied-to-analysis-workspace acceptedPatternFiles: - C001.retry3.json - C002.yaml - C003.yaml - C004.yaml - C005.yaml - C006.retry2.json - C007.retry3.json - C008.yaml - C009.json - C010.retry1.json - C011.json - C012.json - C013.json - C014.retry1.json - C015.json - C016.json - C017.json - C018.json - C019.retry1.json - C020.json - C021.json - C022.json - C023.retry1.json - C024.retry1.json primaryView: denominator: 24 composition: originalH1SelectedCells: 21 supplementalD5ReplacementCells: 3 d5Selection: selectedCampaign: bat-sanitize-matrixspec-harness-evolution-h1-rerun-20260811 originalH1D5Weight: 0 disposition: historical-incident-and-governance-evidence-only aggregate: workflowCompleted: 10 focusedTestsPassed: 18 judgeOutputs: 48 judgeScoreSum: 4489 judgeMean: 93.5208333333 selectedCandidateTokens: 316713117 selectedCandidateCredits: 4460.56 behaviorExclusions: - infrastructure-invalid attempts - arithmetic-invalid Judge output from original H1 D5 - canceled zero-model rejudge and validation20 plans - original H1 D5 behavior and cost - Freeze inventory governance incident confirmation: status: confirmed confirmedWeaknesses: - W-01 - W-03 - W-04 unconfirmedWeaknesses: - W-02 - W-05 note: W-02 and W-05 are not independent Proposal sources; W-02 is not double-counted with W-03 or W-04. weaknesses: - weakness_id: W-01 stable_ref: H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/W-01 title: 跨阶段恢复责任与可达权限不匹配 pattern_refs: - PT-05 first_divergence: >- Validator 首次把上游 tasks/artifact blocker 写入 validation evidence 后， controller 仍只授权 validation，无法执行所请求回退；后续相同 transition 请求无信息增益。 hypothesis: >- 下游角色负责发现上游 blocker，却没有可达 controller transition 来关闭它， 形成“能发现、不能关闭”的 Recovery 断点。 attribution: - Agent Responsibility - Recovery support: analysisCells: - C002 - C010 - C013 affectedRuns: - h1-axum-custom-executor-r2-attempt-01 - h1-eslint-preserve-caught-error-r1-attempt-02 - h1-prometheus-utf8-negotiation-r1-attempt-01 observed: workflowCompleted: 0/3 workflowFailed: 3/3 alternatives: - model stochasticity - task-specific upstream artifact quality - incomplete natural-language handoff counterevidence: - 多数 primary cells 未触发该模式。 - C005、C012、C024 可在反馈后继续修复。 scope: 3 cells across 3 tasks in the primary 24-cell view counterfactual_prediction: >- validation 内重复 transition 请求消失；同类 blocker 产生真实阶段变化或明确 terminal disposition。 confidence: high status: confirmed-derived-falsifiable raw_refs: [] - weakness_id: W-03 stable_ref: H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/W-03 title: 多工件一致性/finalization 闭包不完整 pattern_refs: - PT-02 first_divergence: >- 进入 Implementation 或声明 finalization 前，spec/design/tasks/validation evidence 仍有缺页、矛盾或缺少追溯。 hypothesis: >- 多工件 finalization 的 Verification 边界不完整，使代码或 focused tests 可通过时，Artifact 状态仍未形成一致闭包。 attribution: - Artifact - Verification support: analysisCells: - C006 - C010 - C012 - C016 - C017 - C023 affectedRuns: - h1-bat-sanitize-rerun-20260811-r3-attempt-01 - h1-eslint-preserve-caught-error-r1-attempt-02 - h1-eslint-preserve-caught-error-r3-attempt-03 - h1-pytest-addini-type-expressions-r1-attempt-02 - h1-pytest-addini-type-expressions-r2-attempt-02 - h1-sqlmodel-field-constraints-r2-attempt-01 observed: workflowCompleted: 1/6 focusedTestsPassed: 5/6 judgeOutputs: 12 judgeMean: 94.75 alternatives: - model stochasticity - task-specific documentation complexity - downstream instruction ambiguity counterevidence: - C012 后续修复完成。 - C024 和无 Pattern 的成功 cells 可形成一致闭包。 scope: 6 cells across 4 tasks in the primary 24-cell view; C006 is the authoritative replacement D5 cell counterfactual_prediction: >- “代码/focused 已过，但下游才发现权威工件缺失、矛盾或 trace 不完整”的轨迹减少。 confidence: medium status: confirmed-derived-falsifiable raw_refs: [] - weakness_id: W-04 stable_ref: H1/h1-root-cause-20260811-a/W-04 title: Review blocker 未跨 re-entry 保持可验证闭包 pattern_refs: - PT-01 - PT-02 first_divergence: >- Reviewer 给出 changes-required 后，implementation re-entry 只修复部分问题或 重复已有检查，未关闭全部原 blocker。 hypothesis: >- review-to-implementation handoff 只有自然语言 findings，没有稳定的 blocker closure state，导致部分修复后丢失剩余义务。 attribution: - Information Flow - Recovery - Verification support: analysisCells: - C007 - C009 - C013 - C016 - C023 affectedRuns: - h1-cli-item-list-fields-r1-attempt-06 - h1-cli-item-list-fields-r3-attempt-03 - h1-prometheus-utf8-negotiation-r1-attempt-01 - h1-pytest-addini-type-expressions-r1-attempt-02 - h1-sqlmodel-field-constraints-r2-attempt-01 observed: workflowCompleted: 0/5 focusedTestsPassed: 4/5 judgeOutputs: 10 judgeMean: 92.8 alternatives: - model stochasticity - task-specific review complexity - incomplete implementation evidence counterevidence: - C005、C012、C022、C024 review 后成功修复并获批准。 scope: 5 cells across 4 tasks in the primary 24-cell view counterfactual_prediction: >- re-entry 对原 blocker 的逐项 closure evidence 增加，重复报告同一 blocker 减少。 confidence: medium status: confirmed-derived-falsifiable raw_refs: [] nonAdditivity: statement: Weakness and Proposal support cells and costs overlap and must not be summed. overlappingCells: C010: - W-01 - W-03 C013: - W-01 - W-04 C016: - W-03 - W-04 C023: - W-03 - W-04 evidenceGap: persistedPatternEvidenceFilesInAnalysisWorkspace: 0 acceptedTemporaryPatternEvidenceFiles: 24 rawRefsStatus: validated-in-accepted-temporary-pattern-evidence-not-persisted-to-analysis-workspace note: >- Cell IDs, selected physical runs, outcomes, focused results, Judge scores and selected cost align with the frozen bundle. The 24 accepted Luna outputs were validated for cell identity, input binding, complete segment coverage and raw source path/range references, but the accepted files are still under and are not durably persisted in this analysis workspace.